Even when Nor’easter winter winds are blowing and the majority of the region’s lobster shacks are shuttered for the season, there are still plenty of great places to get a top-notch New England lobster roll. Frequent Yankee Magazine and NewEngland.com contributor Mike Urban shares his expert picks for the the 10 best lobster rolls that will satisfy your wintertime craving for New England’s favorite seafood sandwich.
Where to Find the Best New England Lobster Roll in Winter
Matunuck’s New England lobster roll, with fresh greens tossed in a light vinaigrette.
Matunuck Oyster Bar | South Kingstown, RI
Tucked away on a sliver of land close to the Block Island ferry, this innovative oyster and organic vegetable farm has an excellent cold New England lobster roll that’s served year round in a beautiful setting overlooking the restaurant’s thriving oyster beds. You get five ounces of super-fresh lobster meat, tossed with a bit of mayo, on a leaf of lettuce, all tucked into a toasted bun. The side of choice is definitely the fresh-picked greens from the adjacent organic vegetable farm, much of which is under glass for year-round production.
City Fish Market’s cold (left) and hot (right) lobster rolls.
Kim Knox Beckius
City Fish Market | Wethersfield, CT
This central Connecticut purveyor of all things seafood serves up excellent hot and cold lobster rolls year round. The hot version, which features warm lobster meat bathed in butter, outsells the cold version five to one (this is Connecticut), but both rolls are more than worthy. City Fish gets its lobster from its voluminous lobster tanks, and the toasted, buttered buns come from Mozzicato’s Bakery in nearby Hartford.
Lenny and Joe’s has sold over a million hot New England lobster rolls.
Lenny and Joe’s Fish Tale | Westbrook, CT
A Connecticut shoreline institution since 1979, Lenny and Joe’s claims to have sold over a million hot lobster rolls—and one bite will erase any doubt you may have of such a claim. Served on a toasted, split-top New England hot dog bun, the lobster is plentiful and drenched in sweet, melted butter. The roll pairs nicely with Lenny and Joe’s famous salt potatoes and a cup of clear-broth Rhode Island clam chowder. Cold lobster rolls are also available.
Neptune Oyster Bar’s warm, buttered lobster roll is often named as the best lobster roll in Boston.
Neptune Oyster | Boston, MA
The wait to get a seat in this cramped, dimly lit North End oyster bar can be maddening, but the hefty, warm-buttered lobster roll makes it well worth the effort. Served on a lightly grilled brioche bun from Iggy’s Bread in Cambridge, this six- to seven-ounce roll calls for a fork to lighten the lobster load before getting a grip on the roll itself. The cloth napkins and sterling silverware add an element of class to the place, but it’s as informal and convivial as any trattoria in this famed Italian neighborhood.
The bun is all but buried beneath a half-pound of lobster at Belle Isle Seafood.
Belle Isle Seafood | Winthrop, MA
Perched across an inlet from the runways at Boston’s Logan International Airport, Belle Isle is locally known as the home of the monster lobster roll. Owner Jim Costin loads his lobster sandwich up with a full half-pound of cold, mayo’ed chunks of tail, claw, and knuckle meat and throws in a side of fries, onion rings, coleslaw, or rice pilaf. This belt-busting combination is a favorite of many in the restaurant’s working class neighborhood. For a few dollars more, there’s an equally hefty version of the roll made solely from prized tail meat.
Sanders Fish Market’s round bun and leafy lettuce are nice complements to the fresh-picked lobster.
Sanders Fish Market | Portsmouth, NH
Some of the best lobster rolls come from lobster-fishing and distribution operations, and Sanders is no exception. The market is a spinoff of Sanders Lobster Company, which has been wholesaling lobster from the Portsmouth docks for decades. The Sanders roll distinguishes itself with its round, toasted, buttered bun, its fresh leaf of curly lettuce, and its lovingly fresh-picked lobster meat. Throw in a bag of Cape Cod potato chips, and your New England lobster roll feast is complete.
The chunk-filled lobster roll is one of the favorite menu items at the Maine Diner.
The Maine Diner
Maine Diner | Wells, ME
In addition to the Maine Diner’s famed seafood chowder, there’s an excellent Maine lobster roll that’s served year round and that’s definitely worth stopping in to try. The fresh-picked lobster meat is served chilled on a toasted, split-top hot dog bun and is accompanied with mayo or melted butter. Never underestimate the seafood to be found at some of the Best Diners in New England!
Bob’s lobster roll is a welcome treat just over the border in Kittery, Maine.
Bob’s Clam Hut | Kittery, ME
Just over the border and a stone’s throw from I-95, Bob’s is well known to the summertime crowds heading to and from Maine. This seafood shack is also a great place to go for an excellent lobster roll in the dead of winter. The grilled-bun, cold-meat roll is chock-full of fresh-picked lobster meat and comes with fries and a large dill pickle spear. The colorful dining room is spacious and cozy at the same time.
SEE MORE: Bob’s Clam Hut | Local Flavor
J’s lobster roll features a nice mix of tail, claw, and knuckle meat.
J’s Oyster | Portland, ME
A longtime fixture on the Portland waterfront, J’s is equal parts tavern, oyster bar, and seafood restaurant, serving one of the best lobster rolls in Portland—and it’s available even in deepest, darkest winter. The U-shaped bar is a great place to belly up and order a cold roll served on a piece of crisp lettuce on a toasted, side-split bun and a quaint ballpark-style packet of mayo. The lobster meat is picked locally and brought in fresh daily, guaranteeing consistently high quality.
Eventide’s petite brown-butter lobster roll packs a delightful culinary punch.
Photo by Zack Bowen/Knack Factory
Eventide Oyster Company | Portland, ME
Eventide’s lobster roll is one of the most unusual and exotic to be found in New England, and it’s certainly one of the most satisfying. The warm version is made using clarified brown butter and is served on a home-baked, Asian-style bao bun. Though diminutive in size, its flavor stands tall and distinctive. One roll, accompanied by a few of Eventide’s excellent oysters, is a wintertime meal not soon to be forgotten. Want to recreate the Eventide lobster roll at home? We were delighted when they shared their Brown Butter Lobster Roll recipe in a recent issue of Yankee.
Where’s your favorite spot for a New England lobster roll in the winter? Let us know!
This post was first published in 2017 and has been updated.
10 Best Lobster Rolls in New England
Best Cape Cod Lobster Rolls
12 Best Lobster Shacks in New England
The McDonald’s Lobster Roll Experience
The post Where to Find the Best New England Lobster Roll in Winter appeared first on New England Today.